Skip to content
Blog

When the Pope Names AI a Defining Challenge, Higher Education Cannot Stay Silent

The newly elected Pope used his first public remarks to name artificial intelligence as one of the most pressing challenges of our time. Not war. Not poverty. Not political fracture. AI.

TL;DR

  • Pope Leo XIV named AI as significant as the Industrial Revolution in his very first public remarks, not as a warning, but as a call to stewardship.
  • AI is not a technology issue. It is a human issue. And that makes it the business of every institution responsible for forming people.
  • Leaders who are not using AI daily are already behind, not because they lack information, but because they lack experience.
  • The institutions that will flourish are the ones that trust their superusers and treat them as collaborators, not threats.
  • The old model of centralized control is over. Shared stewardship is what comes next.

I was already paying attention to AI when the announcement came. But this stopped me. Pope Leo XIV, the first American Pope, chose artificial intelligence as the subject of his first public remarks. Before geopolitics. Before the economy. Before any of the urgent human crises, competing for a new pontiff's attention.

He named AI directly. A force as significant as the Industrial Revolution. A technology already reshaping how we live, work, think, and connect with profound social, ethical, and spiritual implications.

He called it a challenge. And he called for stewardship.

That word matters more than any other in his remarks. Stewardship is not the language of fear. It is the language of responsibility. It is what you say when you recognize that something is powerful, consequential, and yours to care for.

THE POPE AND AI

What Pope Leo XIV Actually Said About AI

                           [![](/public/brand/pg/blog/pope-leo-xiv-ai-higher-education-steward-2.png)]()

The Industrial Revolution comparison is worth sitting with.

The Industrial Revolution did not just change how goods were made. It changed how people lived, worked, organized, worshipped, and understood themselves. It reshaped family structures, urban landscapes, religious life, and the meaning of work. It created new forms of inequality and new forms of opportunity. Its effects were total.

That is the scale the Pope is naming.

He also asked the questions that most technology conversations skip. Who do these tools serve? What values are embedded in the systems we are scaling? What kind of future are we shaping, and who gets to decide?

These are not abstract questions for a later moment. They are the questions that determine whether AI becomes a tool for human flourishing or a force that concentrates power, erodes dignity, and replaces judgment with efficiency.

WHAT THIS TELLS LEADERS

When the leader of one of the world's largest institutions names AI as a defining challenge in his opening remarks, the conversation has moved. AI is no longer a technology trend or a faculty senate agenda item. It is a civilization-level question. Higher education has to be part of answering it.

HUMAN OVER AI ALWAYS

AI Is Not a Technology Problem. It Is a Human Problem.

Here is what institutions miss when they frame AI as a policy or compliance challenge.

AI is not reshaping your systems. It is reshaping the people inside them.

The way students learn. The way faculty teach. The way administrators lead. The way people form identity, build knowledge, develop judgment, and make meaning — all of it is being reshaped. And formation is the deepest work of higher education. It has always been.

The Pope named this as a spiritual and ethical issue. I name it as a formation issue. Both are pointing at the same reality: this is not a tool problem. It is a human problem. And human problems require human responses.

What is at stake is not productivity or efficiency. What is at stake is the kind of person your institution is forming — and whether the AI environment your students are navigating is one you have helped design with intention, or one they are navigating alone.

              [![](/public/brand/pg/blog/pope-leo-xiv-ai-higher-education-steward-3.png)]()

WHAT THIS TELLS LEADERS

Every institution responsible for forming people is implicated in this moment. The question is not whether AI is changing your students and your faculty. It is. The question is whether your institution is helping them navigate it or leaving them to figure it out on their own.

Formation, not information. That is the work. The urgency is new. The work is not.

The Pope named it a defining challenge. Your institution still needs a strategy.

Most leaders we work with have the same response: "I know AI is important, but I don't know where my institution actually stands or how to build something that will hold."
You do not need to wait for the technology to stabilize. You need to start where you are.
    [Let's talk about where your institution stands →](/contact)

Here is what building an actual strategy looks like:

  • A values clarification: what does your institution believe about AI, human dignity, and formation?
  • A superuser map: who on your campus is already leading — and how do you bring them in?
  • Faculty and staff development that builds capacity across departments, not just at the top
  • Communication strategy that moves your institution from anxiety to public confidence
  • A partner who has helped institutions build AI cultures that last

YOU CAN'T UNDERSTAND THAT WHICH YOU DON'T USE

The Leaders Who Are Not Using AI Daily Are Already Behind

                           [![](/public/brand/pg/blog/pope-leo-xiv-ai-higher-education-steward-4.png)]()

Here is something I say out loud because it needs to be said. If you are not using AI daily, it is very hard to lead well around it.

Reading about AI is not the same as using it. A one-time workshop is not the same as experimenting, failing, discovering, and adapting alongside the tools themselves. There is a kind of knowledge that comes only from doing. AI is not the exception to that rule.

The leaders who are falling behind are not the ones without information. They have read the reports. They have attended the briefings. They understand the headlines. What they lack is experience. And you cannot fake it in the room.

The faculty member who has been using AI to redesign assignments for six months sees things you cannot see from a policy document. The student using AI as a daily writing partner has built intuitions that no presentation will transfer. The staff member who has integrated AI into their workflow knows what works and what breaks in ways that no report captures.

WHAT THIS TELLS LEADERS

The gap is not informational. It is experiential. And the only way to close it is to start. To pick up the tools, use them imperfectly, and build the working knowledge that actually earns trust in the room. Leaders who want to guide their institutions through this moment have to be willing to be beginners.

LISTEN TO THE SUPER USERS

Trust the People Closest to the Work

The institutions navigating AI well are not the ones with the best policies. They are the ones with leaders who trust their superusers.

Superusers are the people inside your institution who are already living with AI. They are experimenting daily, building practical expertise that no workshop can replicate, and discovering what actually works — and what breaks. They know things you do not. And if you treat them as threats to authority rather than sources of intelligence, you will lose exactly the knowledge your institution needs most.

The leaders who flourish here are not trying to master every tool or keep up with every update. They are listening to the people who already have. They are treating those people as collaborators, not a problem to manage.

The old model, where authority flows from the top and expertise is centrally managed, does not hold here. AI moves too fast, touches too many functions, and changes too often for any one person or any one office to own it.

              [![](/public/brand/pg/blog/pope-leo-xiv-ai-higher-education-steward-5.png)]()

WHAT THIS TELLS LEADERS

The Pope's call to stewardship is not a call to control AI. It is a call to shared responsibility. That means building distributed capacity across your institution — finding the people closest to the work, giving them room to lead, and staying humble enough to learn from them. If a new Pope can name AI as a defining challenge in his first public remarks, the rest of us should stop pretending it can be managed from a policy document.

Stewardship at scale requires more than one leader who gets it. AI First Responders can help.

A single institutional leader, no matter how committed to formation-centered AI strategy, cannot be present in every department meeting, every course design conversation, every moment when a colleague reaches for prohibition instead of engagement. That gap is not a failure of leadership. It is a structural reality.
You do not have to choose between institutional vision and course-level change. The institutions answering this moment are investing in both.
    [Learn about the AI First Responder program →](/ai-first-responder)

The AI First Responder credential trains peer leaders across your institution to fill it:

  • Faculty and staff certified in a practical diagnostic framework
  • Embedded in departments, not housed in a central office
  • Present at the point of need — when the question is real and the stakes are immediate
  • A distributed network that extends your AI leadership into the daily fabric of the institution

What Higher Ed Leaders Can Do Right Now

  1. Start using AI yourself. Not as a demonstration. Not as a talking point. As a daily practice. Choose one workflow — meeting prep, email drafting, research synthesis, and commit to using AI for it every day for thirty days. You cannot lead a conversation you are not in.

  2. Find your superusers and give them real influence. Every campus has people who are already deep in AI experimentation. Identify them across departments. Ask what they are seeing. Make them part of your institutional response—not as a one-time task force, but as ongoing collaborators with a real voice.

  3. Frame AI as a formation issue, not a compliance issue. The institutions building lasting AI cultures start with the question: what kind of thinker, learner, and professional are we forming? Let that question drive the design. Compliance follows from clarity.

  4. Name your stewardship commitments publicly. What does your institution believe about human dignity in the AI era? What values do you want embedded in the systems you are adopting? These questions belong in your strategic plan and your public communication, not just in an ethics committee meeting.

  5. Stop waiting for the technology to stabilize. It will not. The window for leading proactively is now. Institutions that wait for certainty will inherit decisions made by others. The leaders who shape this moment are the ones who show up before they feel ready.

The stewardship the Pope is calling for is not just a spiritual challenge. It is an institutional one. And it cannot be answered from a policy document. It requires the kind of distributed, formation-centered leadership capacity that most institutions have not yet built. The AI First Responder credential trains peer leaders across your institution to carry that stewardship into every classroom, every curriculum conversation, and every moment when a colleague reaches for fear rather than strategy. If your institution is ready to answer the call, not just to name AI as a challenge, but to lead through it with wisdom and confidence. This is the work.

    [Learn more](/ai-first-responder)

COMMON QUESTIONS

Frequently Asked Questions

What did Pope Leo XIV say about artificial intelligence?

In his first public remarks as Pope, Leo XIV named artificial intelligence as one of the most pressing challenges of our time, placing it alongside the Industrial Revolution in scale and significance. He identified the social, ethical, and spiritual implications of AI as present realities, not future concerns, and called for stewardship: a commitment to asking who these tools serve, what values are built into them, and what kind of future they are shaping. His framing was not alarmist. It was a call to wisdom and responsibility.

How should faith-based institutions respond to the AI era?

Faith-based institutions have a unique contribution to make to the AI conversation: they carry a language and a tradition for discussing human dignity, formation, community, and moral accountability that many technology conversations lack. The faithful response to AI is not avoidance or prohibition. It is engaged stewardship to ask who AI serves, what it makes possible for the most vulnerable, and whether the systems being adopted align with the institution's mission and values. These questions should be central, not peripheral, to any AI strategy.

What does AI stewardship mean in practice for higher education?

Stewardship means being responsible for something beyond yourself, not just managing it, but caring for it and for those affected by it. In higher education, AI stewardship means adopting tools intentionally rather than reactively: asking what AI is for before deploying it, building capacity distributed across the institution rather than controlled by a single office, and staying accountable to the students, faculty, and communities whose lives your AI decisions shape. It looks less like policy enforcement and more like an ongoing institutional conversation.

Why is hands-on experience with AI more important than reading about it?

AI knowledge is experiential. You can read extensively about AI and still fundamentally misread what is happening on your campus because the gap is not informational; it is experiential. Using AI daily builds the kind of intuition that only comes from doing: knowing how tools actually behave, what they fail at, where they surprise you, and what that means for how you lead. Leaders who have that experience see things that leaders without it cannot. The only way to close that gap is to start using the tools, imperfectly, and build from there.

What is the superuser principle and how does it apply to institutional AI leadership?

The superuser principle recognizes that the deepest and most current AI knowledge inside an institution usually lives not at the top of the org chart, but with the faculty, staff, and students who are already experimenting with AI in their daily work. Effective AI leadership means identifying those people, listening to them, and incorporating their expertise into how the institution responds, not as a threat to authority, but as a source of institutional intelligence. The leaders who navigate AI well are those who have built relationships with their superusers and given them real influence over institutional direction.

How should higher education leaders move from AI anxiety to AI strategy?

The shift begins with a values clarification: what does this institution believe about human formation, human dignity, and the purpose of learning? That foundation makes every subsequent decision more coherent because strategy follows from clarity about mission. Leaders who skip the values step and go straight to tools and policies end up reactive, building defenses against technology rather than shaping how it serves their people. The move from anxiety to strategy is not primarily a technology move. It is a leadership move. It starts with the question every good leader knows how to ask: what are we actually here to do?

Let's talk.

If you are leading an institution through this moment and you are not sure where to start, that is exactly what I do.

                 [Request a consultation](/book-a-call)

Sarah Gibson is the former Director of the School of Communication and Faculty Fellow for AI at Lipscomb University and founder of PivotPoint EDU. She speaks and teaches at the intersection of AI, ethics, and faith, helping higher education institutions and nonprofits move from AI anxiety to AI strategy with clarity and confidence. Learn more.

            Comment 0 Comments      JD
Share

← Back to the blog